Tuesday, March 24, 2009

Why Mohd.Afzal deserves mercy

Even as the BJP seeks to make the non-hanging of Mohd.Afzal, the lone convict in the Parliament attack case facing death penalty, as a major campaign issue, the facts in the MHA files show that he indeed deserves mercy. And Afzal's mercy petition itself did not get the media attention that it merits, even though it was the only mercy petition to have been published (in 2007) so far. In two separate articles in latest Frontline, Bikram Jeet Batra and I examine his case with an eye for historical and contemporary details here and here.


Amit Bindal said...

I wanted a clarification...does the supreme court in it's judgment anywhere gives a utilitarian sort of justification that community consciousness makes him deserve such sentence or the sorts, in spite of other things.
I wanted to know this as this point was made by Arundhati Roy in last year's seminar as ISIL, organised by judicial reforms group led by prashant bhushan. Further, somewhat similar point was also made by Ram Puniyani in an article published in countercurrents...So i would like someone who has read the judgment to kindly tell me about it.

Talha said...


is the link for judgement. CTRL+F for conscience and you would find out the exact text.